“Right tool for the job” or “The medium is the message”

Yankee HandymanGiven the rapidly changing landscape of media and media relations these days, if there were one piece of accumulated knowledge I could pass on to young PR practitioners — or young journalists, for that matter — it would be something along the lines of what my father told me decades ago, likely on one of those Saturday mornings out in the work shed at the back of our home: “Use the right tool for the job.”

In my media relations work, I’ve come over time to translate such advice to mean that one should use the appropriate media platform for communicating your message or that of your client — whether it’s to journalists or bloggers, it doesn’t much matter. There’s always a most appropriate media platform for communicating to a specific community. Of course, long before I figured that one out, Marshall McLuhan said it so succinctly with the phrase “The medium is the message,” meaning of course that the medium used invariably influences how the message is perceived.

As a journalist, I worked across multiple media platforms, writing sometimes in the morning about breaking news in a very brief, wire-service format; and covering it later that day in a longer newspaper piece, or even weaving the same news into a magazine feature with a longer deadline. The platforms were all very different and took into account their readership. But the lesson was simple, you would never file a 350-word breaking news story to a magazine editor, nor would you submit a 3,500 feature-length piece for a wire service editor. Right tool for the job!

In media relations, one would never submit a lengthy press release over a wire service to a TV news producer who may be sending out a camera team for an enterprise shoot for the evening news. Nor, these days, would one send to a blogger a social media-averse news release, that is, one that is not link-rich, with multimedia options, easy drop quotes, graphic images, bookmarking and social network sharing capabilities. Right tool for the job!

Increasingly, one also needs to pay close attention to the preferences of media practitioners — not just bloggers, but journalists as well — as to how they expect to be contacted. If they say on their voice mail to NEVER call them with a story pitch, you proceed to do so at your peril — and the possible peril of your client’s story. Some say only to contact them via e-mail (though we all know everybody’s email is packed with spam these days); others say only to contact them through social media; others say NEVER to contact them via social media. In all of these cases, it’s imperative that you use the right media platform to communicate with your targeted journalist or blogger.

In the ever-changing media world we live in, there is no substitute for following your journalists and bloggers across every media platform they use to disseminate news and information and to knowing precisely which media platform through which they prefer to receive communication from PR and media relations specialists. To ignore their preferences and use the wrong media platform sends them a very clear message, either that you don’t care about their instructions as to how to contact them or that you just “don’t get it” when it comes to the media in which they work … or both!

In media relations as in most things, you have first to be familiar with and then know when and how to use … and here I say it again, at the risk of sounding both pompous and redundant: The right tool for the job!

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

Arts & Letters Daily: ‘Best Website in the World’



Mr. Big thought he knew a lot about websites and about the Internet generally. So, it was a humbling experience to have been completely unaware of the existence for more than a decade of Arts & Letters Daily, until it was brought to my attention by the real intellectual and authority on all things ‘arts & letters’ in my family.

At the time, I was surprised to see that the site is published by The Chronicle of Higher Education, for which I wrote fairly extensively for a time on university and higher-ed happenings in Mexico and Central America. But, I digress …

I’m now even more surprised to read the history of the site on Wikipedia and to learn that it was founded way back in 1998, long before The Chronicle got involved, by one Denis Dutton, Los Angeles-born and New Zealand-resident professor of Philosophy, web entrepreneur and media commentator/activist of some reknown.

I can’t say enough good things about this site, which was named by the Sunday Observer in 1999 as “Best Website in the World.” I concur … and made it the home page of my default web browser some time ago, just to be able to see the latest every time I go to the net.

ALDaily.com has something for everyone interested in media, with breaking news stories at sites galore throughout the English-speaking world; plus synopses and links to the best of the best articles, book reviews, essays, literary and social criticism available in English across the web today. It’s full of everything that really matters to anyone who cares to occasionally step back from the fast-paced, consumption-driven madness of the world we inhabit and send an intelligent thought or reflection from one nerve synapse to another!

I think it may still be the ‘Best Website in the World’ …

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

Miami dot.com to Miami 2.0: What have we learned?

Miami 2.0So, let’s start with a confession … I was the ‘Silicon Beach Buzz’ werewolf!

Yes, that’s right … moonlighting after hours back in late-1999 and early-2000, I put out a guerrilla e-newsletter that exploded virally as everyone jumped on the bandwagon (eventually, my good self included!) of the South Florida-based Internet startup phenomenon, comprised largely of Latin American and Spanish-language content portals for just about everything you can imagine — from finance to trade to health to women’s issues and music.

By end-2000, though, Silicon Beach was in serious trouble along with most other dot.com-era startup zones, from Silicon Valley to Austin, from Boston to San Diego to Raleigh-Durham and beyond. Those in South Florida tech who barely managed to stay afloat through the economic doldrums of 2001 were largely put to rest by 9/11 and the shock waves that sent throughout the U.S. economy.

I’ve returned to the somewhat painful reminiscence of less happy days for the South Florida dot.com boom & bust prompted by a coupla three things: one is Stuart Bruce’s reference to the “hype cycle” that accompanies new technologies, in his post about Twitter’s current location on the expectation curve; another is having just reviewed my post of last year at this time about Miami’s tech revival of a different kind in this era of Web 2.0; the other is a really insightful blog post by Jeremiah Owyang I spotted more than a year ago and kept archived, titled Commemorating the Idiocy of the Dot Com Era: Did we Repeat or Reform?

For anyone who wasn’t here, you might ask “Repeat what?” or “Reform What?” For myself, I’m thinking there appear to be quite a few lessons learned that have fortunately since seeped into the general tech and web community consciousness. But, I’d like to enlist the help of some of those who were here then and those who are here now to get their input and insight into exactly what we have learned from Miami dot.com to Web 2.0.

A quick bit of history: from 1998-2001, there appeared a plethora of dot.coms that were spread throughout South Beach and the Design District and up into Aventura, Broward and beyond. There were the notables StarMedia, Yupi.com, ElSitio.com and Patagon.com — whose CEO, Argentine Wenceslao Casares, managed a multi-million dollar sale to Spain’s Banco Santander just prior to the bubble’s burst, perhaps the only truly successful execution of a financial exit for any of the Silicon Beach startups.

But there were many, many more … I left journalism to manage online content at 1hemisphere.com, a b2b e-commerce portal promoting cross-border trade between small- to mid-sized enterprises throughout the Americas. Talk about an idea whose time had/has not yet come!!

For anyone wanting to search the history, still out there is a graveyard of press releases and announcements that read like so many epitaphs on tombstones: partnerships, product releases, closed rounds of funding; even the occasional NYTimes story about a phenomenon that appeared to be promising, yet would soon run out of gas before getting off the runway.

Perhaps the best litany of Miami dot.com startups that literally “went South” can be found in a Hispanic Business magazine article in January 2001 — though I caution if you’re going to read that piece that never, ever did I hear anyone call what was happening here “Silicon Playa.” (Hey, I was Silicon Beach Buzz! so I know … and anyway, that would be like calling the Bay Area “Frisco” … but I digress.) And, David Adams filed a creditable piece for the St. Pete Times months earlier.

When all is said and done, the real question for me from Miami dot.com to Miami 2.0 is … “What have we learned?” Why is it different this time around? What have we taken from that earlier experience of the “static web” and VCs-gone-wild to the current “live web” era and the Web 2.0-driven technology scene that has been developing for awhile now in South Florida.

The past of Miami dot.com is well known. The future of Miami 2.0 is yours to write. Looking forward to your reminiscences, insight and comments!

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

Stuart Bruce, Twitter and the ‘peak of inflated expectation’

6a00d83451674169e201156fd9f7dd970c
Love this graphic from Stuart Bruce, the Gartner Hype Cycle, pointing out how Twitter and micro-blogging are presently “at the peak of inflated expectation,” as were Facebook, Second Life, blogs and e-Commerce previously.

Also like what Stuart calls the “slope of enlightenment,” evidently that second wave of more rational expectation of the true value of these new technologies and platforms. The value in Twitter is clearly there, as is the value in Facebook and other social media platforms.

But, the hype is just way beyond rationality for Twitter at its current “peak of inflated expectation.” Soon, we’ll return to a more reasoned appreciation … and then we’ll hit the next peak!

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

News Flash: the Internet did NOT, repeat NOT, kill journalism as we knew it



Anybody get a chance to see David Simon’s National Press Club luncheon speech last week? Brilliant! Check it out … here.

Simon, the creator of HBO’s “The Wire” and former Baltimore Sun reporter, has been seen and heard a lot lately and there is lots of YouTube video of him on Bill Moyers Journal, Real Time with Bill Maher, speaking at Loyola College, USC Law School, testifying before the U.S. Senate (in a controversial appearance with Ariana Huffington) about the future of U.S. Newspapers …

I caught his luncheon speech at the National Press Club on Monday June 8th via C-Span and … it’s riveting. It asserts what some of us have been saying all along … it’s been the full-scale capitulation of management to the short-term, balance-sheet dictates of Wall Street equity analysts that’s really bludgeoned the newspaper industry over the past 20 years or so. The rise of new technology is a straw dog argument.

Simon is much more articulate on this than I’ve ever been … it’s longish, but skip through the intros on this video and go right to his speech. It’s well worth it!

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

So much blood, you can’t even see the floor any more

I was discussing last week at lunch with Alex DC the rapid demise of the US newspaper industry and the fate of the Boston Globe, which as we munched at Tarpon Bend was hanging in the balance. It gained a reprieve, however brief that might be, over the weekend as all but one of the paper’s unions conceded to management. More news TK, as they used to say …

Decided to go back nearly a year to my post of June 16, 2008, Blood on the floor: McClatchy cuts 60 newsroom jobs at Miami Herald, to check out the Google map mashup that St. Louis Post-Dispatch journalist and graphic designer Erica Smith had chronicled. At the time of my post last June, Smith had recorded and mapped a total of 3,329 jobs lost at newspapers nationwide in the first six months of ‘08, in addition to more than 2,000 job cuts in the last seven months of 2007.

The current total of layoffs and buyouts at U.S. newspapers so far in 2009? A shocking 8,922 and counting. The latest chronicled blood-letting is at the San Diego Union-Tribune, my old alma mater for which I reported from Mexico and Central America in the mid-1980s. The former flagship of the Copley newspaper chain laid off 190 workers today under new ownership.

See Erica’s forlorn map of newspaper layoffs now by clicking on the image below. So much blood, you can’t even see the newsroom floor anymore.

Picture1

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

MoMo Miami, social networks and community building

mmmiami_mmshare-siteI’ve been posting to MobileMonday Miami lately, part of our efforts to re-boot the local South Florida chapter of MobileMonday, the global community of mobile industry professionals started in 2000 in Helsinki and now with 67-plus chapters around the world.

Apart from the satisfaction of seeing mobile revive in Miami after the one-two punch that hit the Latin Internet startups here in 2000-01 and then the global telecoms shakeout that followed shortly thereafter, I’m seeing a lot of interesting things in the process of the MoMo Miami community building. And, by that I mean the specific appropriateness of relying on MoMo Miami groups on social networking platforms like LinkedIn, Facebook and Plaxo to attract the players or members of the local mobile ecosystem.


View Larger Map

What is really interesting to me is that no single platform seems to bring together all the members of the mobile ecosystem (or mobile “value chain” as they used to say in the not-distant past) to the extent that is necessary to have a really vibrant, thriving and healthy mobile community.

The immediate goal is to reach and facilitate communications among all the players in the ecosystem — from developers of applications and solutions to web designers and advertising creatives, to providers of content from traditional print and broadcast outlets, to social media and mobility startups and mobile device manufacturers and network service providers. And, the ultimate goal — since this is fundamentally a business community — is to connect them in such a way that there are shared benefits for everyone, with plenty of creativity and remuneration to keep everyone satisfied.

What one finds immediately in trying to facilitate this is that very different segments of the mobility world are using different social networking platforms — not to mention other means of networking and certainly not all of them online. Finding the most appropriate platforms to reach each of those segments of the local mobile community is proving to be an interesting challenge, to say the least.

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

Many months and four books …

Many months and four books … or, some of what I read over the period I was away from the blogosphere & part of why I’m back.

• Millenial Makeover: My Space, YouTube and the Future of American Politics; Morley Winograd & Michael D. Hais

• Generations: The History of America’s Future, 1584 to 2069; William Strauss & Neil Howe

• Click: What Millions of People do Online and Why it Matters; Bill Tancer

• Born Digital: Understanding the First Generation of Digital Natives; John Palfrey & Urs Gasser

Impactful books I highly recommend, but still only part of why I’m back. Another reason is the impression made on me by the rapid implosion of print media in the United States over the past few months, which although foreseen for some time by many of us, has been stunning in its sheer velocity, nonetheless.

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

Mr. Big is back!

mr-bigAfter a necessary pause, hiatus, breather … Mr. Big is back!

Promise I’ll be posting when I have “something to say”; and when not, not. Interests continue to be the notion of “community’ and communities’ preferences for particular media platforms for receiving news and information, for generating the same and their collective determinations of what is newsworthy and what is not.

The evolution of communities’ gatekeeping their news and information is of particular interest, as is the how and when and why of their choice to allow themselves to be interrupted with communications and when and how and why they give permission for communications with them.

And, lots of related information about how all of the above is impacting the business of media and communications and our collective ability to maintain and promote the credibility and free flow of information in our world. And yadayadayada …

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif

Th-Th-Th-Th-Th-Th-Th-Th-Th-Thats all folks!

When I started blogging two years ago about the impact of technology on news media and, by extension, the practice of public relations, I did so because I was confident I had something to say – some experience about media to “share” – and in a combination that provided a perspective I wasn’t seeing elsewhere on media blogs, tech blogs or PR blogs.

And, I told myself that as long as I had something new or fresh to say I would continue – and if not, would not.

I also sensed that the very process of blogging and exchanging views with those who might bother to read this blog would further inform my opinions – and it has and for that, to everyone who’s ever commented on my posts or sent backchannel e-mail comments, I thank you for having helped to broaden my viewpoint considerably.

So, obviously, I’m about to end this particular blogging experience with this one last post. And as I do, I’m pleased to have found that the experience hasn’t fundamentally altered the basic premise I started out with, which I’d summed up in a formula that was the basis for the blog’s title:

Concise Message + Defined Community + Precise Platform + Timely Delivery → Media Mindshare

Everything intuited in that formula has since been borne out in my experience, namely that every community with which/whom one wants to engage to share information about a product/service/occurrence/idea requires not only a concise message, but also clear identification of the most appropriate media platform/vehicle for engaging with that community.

A greater understanding of the way in which Web 2.0 software and platforms are dramatically impacting the sharing of news and information has reinforced my belief that blogs and social networks and messaging platforms are most appropriate for engaging with certain communities – while convincing me that they do not yet and possibly never will supplant other media platforms (including traditional print and broadcast media, live events and conferences, etc.) as the most appropriate platforms for engaging with other, defined communities.

To say it another way, what is clear to me now is what I’d sensed at the outset: that while Web 2.0 has lengthened and broadened substantially the long tail of media, despite the excitement I share with some tech and PR Web 2.0 evangelists, it is still not close to replacing traditional media as the most appropriate means of communicating with most people. And, if that holds true in North America today, in Europe and elsewhere the case for the advancement of both traditional media and online media hand-in-hand — rather than the supplanting of the former by the latter — seems even stronger to me.

I believe that by focusing so much on Web 2.0 capabilities from a purist’s standpoint some tech and PR bloggers actually overlook what I consider to be the Web 2.0 revolution’s most important contributions – the current incorporation by traditional and mainstream media of elements of Web 2.0 technology and philosophy, making them more agile in gathering and delivering news and information and in the process more responsive to the communities of readers and viewers and listeners they serve or represent.

Having said all that, I was about to embark on a list of “what I’ve learned over the past two years” with this blogging experience. But, on second thought … I’ve decided I won’t bore you! All I’ve had to say and share and most of what I’ve learned can be found in the “categories” cloud in the right-hand column or you might want to check out the “top five faves” posts listed there.

This doesn’t necessarily mean I’ve left the social media realm and I’m sure to continue bookmarking my favorite blog posts and online news at del.icio.us; you’ll probably also see me around the ’sphere commenting from time to time on favorite blogs, or see me sharing links to posts and videos and news and events on Facebook or via Twitter.

So, I guess it’s not a real Adiós at all. Which is good, because I’ve always preferred ¡Hasta la vista!

See ya ’round …

E-mail this:add to del.icio.us Bookmark this:add to del.icio.us Digg it myyahoo.gif